top of page
Search

The Worst Pastor for Your Growth Might Be the One You Always Agree With

Oct 5
3 min read

Here’s a crazy thought:

One of the worst things for your spiritual growth might be finding a pastor you completely agree with.

Now, I’m not saying you should intentionally find a pastor you disagree with. Disagreement doesn’t automatically make someone right, and challenging people just for the sake of challenging them isn’t spiritual maturity.

But think about this:

If I only listen to people who already agree with me, how will I ever discover where I need to grow?

We Naturally Want to Hear What We Already Believe

Paul warned Timothy that a time would come when people would no longer endure sound doctrine:

“For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine; but after their own lusts shall they heap to themselves teachers, having itching ears;”— 2 Timothy 4:3 KJV

That warning is incredibly relevant today.

Notice that Paul didn’t just warn about false teachers appearing. He warned about people looking for teachers who would tell them what they wanted to hear.

That means deception doesn’t always sound offensive.

Sometimes deception sounds incredibly comforting.

Sometimes it confirms exactly what we already wanted to believe.

And that is what can make it dangerous.

A Deceiver Needs Something From You

Here’s something we need to understand:

A deceiver will tell you what you want to hear to get what they want.

If someone needs your approval, your money, your attendance, your loyalty, or your support, there can be tremendous pressure to keep you happy.

But someone committed to truth has a different responsibility.

They have to stick with the truth no matter what it costs.

If telling you the truth means you get upset, truth is still truth.

If it means you leave, truth is still truth.

If it means attendance drops, truth is still truth.

If it means people stop giving, truth is still truth.

If it means people speak badly about them, truth is still truth.

Jesus gave a warning that should make every Christian—and especially every leader—think:

“Woe unto you, when all men shall speak well of you! for so did their fathers to the false prophets.”— Luke 6:26 KJV

Being disliked doesn’t prove someone is right. But being willing to compromise truth just to remain liked can become incredibly dangerous.

A Good Pastor Should Challenge You to Grow

Someone who genuinely cares about you doesn’t want you to stay exactly where you are.

Think about parenting.

A good parent loves their child exactly where they are, but because they love them, they also want to see them mature.

Pastoral leadership should have that same heart.

A good pastor should challenge you to pray deeper.

To study Scripture for yourself.

To forgive when you would rather hold onto bitterness.

To repent when you’re wrong.

To serve when you would rather be served.

To trust God when you’re afraid.

To surrender areas you’ve been holding onto.

To become more like Jesus.

That means sometimes the sermon that helps you the most might be the one you enjoyed the least.

Sometimes growth hurts.

But Your Pastor Isn't the Standard

There is another side of this that is extremely important.

Your pastor isn't automatically right because they disagree with you.

Pastors are human.

They can misunderstand Scripture. They can make mistakes. They can have preferences and opinions just like everyone else.

That’s why the goal isn't blind agreement with a pastor.

The goal is agreement with God.

When something challenges you, don't immediately reject it because you don't like it—but don't blindly accept it because a pastor said it either.

Take it to Scripture.

Pray about it.

Study it.

Seek God.

Ask whether your discomfort is because something is actually wrong—or because God is exposing something in you that needs to change.

There is a huge difference.

Don't Look for Comfortable—Look for Truth

Maybe we've been asking the wrong question when looking for a church.

Instead of only asking:

“Do I agree with this pastor?”

Maybe we should ask:

“Does this pastor continually point me toward Jesus and Scripture?”

“Am I being challenged to grow?”

“Am I being encouraged to seek God for myself?”

“Would this pastor still preach this if everyone in the room disagreed?”

Because someone trying to use you has a reason to keep you happy.

Someone who truly loves you has a reason to help you grow.

And someone committed to truth must remain committed to it regardless of the cost.

You don't need a pastor whose goal is to make you comfortable staying exactly where you are.

You need biblical leadership that loves you where you are, points you toward Jesus, and believes God has far too much for you to leave you there.

Don't search for someone who always tells you what you want to hear.

Find people who love you enough to tell you the truth—and then search the Scriptures to make sure what they're telling you really is truth.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page